2022 Archived Content

Forensics & Post-Incident Diagnostics & Testing

Part of the Engineering for Safety Stream

October 13 - 14, 2022 ALL TIMES EDT

In this conference, the latest developments in testing, diagnostics and post incident forensics which are critical for predicting and controlling the complex electrochemical, thermal, and mechanical behavior of LIBs will be presented. With streams focusing on both chemistry and engineering for safety, the 12th Annual Battery Safety Summit will bring together the key players from around the world to present the latest R&D advancements for integrating and implementing LIB safety to meet global battery market demand.

Thursday, October 13

Registration Open1:00 pm

ABUSE TOLERANCE AND ADVANCED TESTING

1:55 pm

Chairperson's Remarks

Vidyu Challa, PhD, Reliability Manager, ANSYS, Inc.

2:00 pm

Thermal Propagation Analysis of Various Trigger Methods Using a Test Bench with Simplified Multi-Cell Setup

Bjoern Mulder, Systems Engineer, HV Batteries, Mercedes Benz AG

This study investigates the consistency of the thermal propagation reaction resulting from nail penetration, overheating, and overcharging of a single cell within a pouch cell pack. The experimental setup allows for the measurement of temperature, voltage, and for various exhaust gas properties. A statistical analysis of these resulting quantities is used to identify the reproducibility of the different trigger methods. Finally, the influence of the particular test chamber and operator are studied, using the trigger method identified as most reproducible.

2:30 pm

Thermal Propagation, Internal Short Resistance, and Nail Penetration of Li-ion Thermal Runaway

John Zhang, PhD, CTO/CSO, Asahi Kasei SSBU Polypore, Celgard LLC

As we presented previously, the thermal runaway of the Li-ion depends on the max power generated on the internal short spots. This paper will address the cell design influence of the max power generation and the needed measurements of various internal short impedances of the Li-ion cells. The images of the real cell internal short will be presented and discussed.

Networking Refreshment Break in the Exhibit Hall with Poster Viewing3:00 pm

3:30 pm

Battery Safety Assessment Using Calorimetry, Gas Chromatography, and Mass Spectroscopy

Carlos Ziebert, PhD, Head of Calorimeter Center, Thermophysics & Thermodynamics Group, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology

For LIB, a holistic safety assessment is in the focus, because the thermal runaway can have multiple interacting causes and effects. A test in an Accelerating Rate Calorimeter (ARC) reveals the entire process of the thermal runaway with the different stages of exothermic reactions. As a result quantitative and system relevant data for temperature, heat and pressure development of materials and cells are provided. In addition it will be explained how calorimeters can be combined with gas chromatography and mass spectroscopy to analyse the gases, which are occurring during abuse tests.

4:00 pm

Understanding the Quality of Lithium-ion Cells with Destructive and Diagnostic Testing

Judith Jeevarajan, PhD, Vice President and Executive Director, Electrochemical Safety Research Institute, UL Research Institutes

The increased demand for li-ion cells and batteries for a multitude of applications from portable electronics to electric vehicles and battery stationary grid energy storage systems has led to its production with low quality and questionable safety. Counterfeit cells and batteries can be purchased with a quick turnaround time and at low cost with the same label as OEMs. UL ESRI's nominal and off-nominal testing along with destructive analysis has confirmed that these products neither meet the label specifications nor have the required self-protective devices that are required to operate under off-nominal conditions. 

4:30 pmSession Break and Transition to Tutorial

CONFERENCE TUTORIALS

5:00 pmTUT1: Battery Safety and Abuse Tolerance Validation*

*Separate registration required. Click here for details.

Close of Day6:30 pm

Friday, October 14

Morning Coffee8:30 am

8:50 am

Organizer's Remarks

Craig Wohlers, Executive Director, Conferences, Cambridge EnerTech

8:55 am

Chairperson's Remarks

Judith Jeevarajan, PhD, Vice President and Executive Director, Electrochemical Safety Research Institute, UL Research Institutes

ABUSE TOLERANCE, ADVANCED TESTING & MODELING

9:00 am

Thermal Propagation Tests on Module and System Level

Roland Bunse, CEO, REMBE Research + Technology Center GmbH

The presentation deals with thermal propagation tests at module and system level. The various test results of these investigations will be presented in the presentation.

9:30 am

Modeling Thermal Runaway in Electric Vehicle Crash Simulations

Vidyu Challa, PhD, Reliability Manager, ANSYS, Inc.

Kevin Kong, PhD, Senior Applications Engineer, ANSYS, Inc.

Battery Thermal runaway testing is expensive and destructive and is generally done in a limited manner. Simulation tools can be used to complement and reduce physical testing. This paper will present a workflow from single cell experiments to full crash modeling. In order to correlate mechanical deformations to the onset of internal shorting, and subsequent appearance of thermal runaway, crush experiments on pouch cells were performed. Benchmarks between experimental and numerical results from LS-DYNA allowed the tune up of cell dependent parameters. The cells were then used in different simulations of full electric vehicle crash.

BATTERY SAFETY BEYOND LITHIUM

10:00 am

Safety Assurance for beyond Lithium-ion Chemistries

Halle Cheesman, Program Director, Advanced Research Program Agency, U.S. Department of Energy (ARPA-E)

Lithium-Ion has had a colorful safety history but now is a commodity we mostly understand. But, what about the, “beyond lithium-ion”, chemistries that are coming. The many flavors of lithium metal, including ASSB, liquid electrolyte, and hybrids. What about Sodium, Magnesium & Aluminum waiting in the wings. This presentation will look at de-risking these technologies sooner rather than later and some of the tools that should be proactively applied.

Networking Coffee Break in the Exhibit Hall with Poster Viewing10:30 am

11:00 am Application of Cyclic Coulometry to Safety and Abuse testing of Fast Charge Batteries

Steve Weiss, President, Xilectric, Inc.

This talk will introduce Xilectric’s new electrochemical method, Cyclic Coulometry, and its application to qualifying batteries for fast charge.  Fast charge battery materials and designs must be inherently stable to fast charge conditions.  They must also present minimal irreversible capacity fade.  This talk will discuss how Xilectric’s new test hardware and protocols can be developed into a standardized abuse test as a measure of fast-charge resilience.

11:15 am PANEL DISCUSSION:

Battery Safety – The Promise versus Reality

PANEL MODERATOR:

Brian Barnett, PhD, President, Battery Perspectives

The roadmap to 2030 offers many opportunities, but not without major safety challenges. A panel of experts will discuss forecasts for 2030, providing insights about opportunities, challenges, barriers, and key factors shaping the 2030 roadmap to safer batteries.

PANELISTS:

Eric C. Darcy, PhD, Battery Technical Discipline Lead, Power Systems, NASA Johnson Space Center

Troy Hayes, PhD, Principal Engineer, Materials & Corrosion Engineering, Exponent, Inc.

Roland Bunse, CEO, REMBE Research + Technology Center GmbH

Wenzel Prochazka, PhD, Senior Product Manager, Battery Systems, AVL List GmbH

12:15 pmEnjoy Lunch on Your Own
12:30 pmPoster Session for our Virtual Poster Presenters and Attendees in Toucan

Poster sessions are an opportunity for our virtual attendees to network and for our virtual poster presenters to present their work to our virtual attendees with the Toucan platform. The link to join this session will be posted in the virtual meeting rooms when we come to this point in the agenda.

VIRTUAL POSTER 1: Wide Tab Design to Improve Cell's Thermal Stability
Jingyuan Liu, General Motors      

VIRTUAL POSTER 2: Examination and Modeling of Thermal Runaway on Li-ion Battery Impact of Chemistry, SOC, and Aging 
Sara Abada, IFP Energies Nouvelles          

VIRTUAL POSTER 3: Beyond Aging Test: Next-Generation Pre-Shipping Quality Control System Using Electric Current Distribution Visualizing Technology
Kenjiro Kimura, Kobe University

VIRTUAL POSTER 4: Influence of Lithium Metal Deposition on the Thermal Stability: DSC Analysis of Cyclic Aged Lithium Metal Batteries 
Lukas Hellweg, University of Muenster, MEET Battery Research Center     

VIRTUAL POSTER 5: In situ Test Rig for Battery Abuse Testing with High-Speed X-Ray Imaging
Jonas Pfaff, Fraunhofer EMI       

VIRTUAL POSTER 6: New Passive Thermal Management for xEV Li Ion Battery 
Sam K., DuPont Water and Protections

VIRTUAL POSTER 7: Thermal Propagation Analysis of Various Trigger Methods Using a Test Bench with Simplified Multi-Cell Setup
Bjoern Mulder, Systems Engineer, HV Batteries, Mercedes Benz AG

PREDICTIVE FAILURE MODELING

1:25 pm

Chairperson's Remarks

Brian Barnett, PhD, President, Battery Perspectives

1:30 pm

Lithium Battery Failure Analysis – Process Overview & the Case for Using a Third-Party Provider

John Copeland, Founder & CTO, Energy Assurance LLC

Is your organization prepared to handle a serious lithium battery field event?  In this presentation, we will cover key considerations with a particular focus on the pros and cons of engaging a third-party failure analysis provider.  This will be further expanded into tips for working with such providers as well as what you should and should not expect.

FORENSIC ANALYSIS

2:00 pm

Investigating the Ability of Plastic Current Collectors to Isolate Internal Shorts

Eric C. Darcy, PhD, Battery Technical Discipline Lead, Power Systems, NASA Johnson Space Center

Metallized plastic current collectors in Li-ion cells reduce mass and reduce the internal short circuit hazard compared to aluminum and copper foils. Shorts induced by nail and by our internal short circuit device were performed on control 18650 cells and on cells with the collectors replaced with metallized polyester and aramid films. Tests were performed inside our fractional thermal runaway calorimeter to quantify the heat transferred and its distributions and those runs done at a synchrotron yielded fascinating very high speed X-ray videography. These show tolerance to nail penetration and activation of defect internal shorts and when thermally forced into thermal runaway, the heat output is significantly reduced. Very high resolution CT scans, cross sections, and cell tear downs give insights into the thermal and mechanism for these plastic collectors.

Networking Refreshment Break in the Exhibit Hall with Poster Viewing2:30 pm

3:00 pm

Mechanical Damages of Lithium-ion Batteries: Aging, Signal Behavior, and Safety

Markus Spielbauer, Research Associate, Munich University of Applied Sciences, Technical University of Munich

In various applications, lithium-ion batteries can be exposed to external mechanical damages, which may remain undetected, resulting in their continued usage. As the interaction of cell-external deformation with cell-internal forces may pose a significant long-term hazard, the cyclic aging behavior, electrical behavior (capacity, DVA, EIS) for potential damage detection, and safety behavior of damaged cells were characterized. Additionally, CT, SEM, and Post Mortem analysis was conducted to improve the understanding of external mechanical deformation in the aging process.

3:30 pm

Advanced Lithium-ion Battery Failure Analysis: An Evolving Methodology for an Evolving Technology

Troy Hayes, PhD, Principal Engineer, Materials & Corrosion Engineering, Exponent, Inc.

Lithium-ion batteries continue to become more and more prolific around the world. With higher energy densities and capacities in today’s lithium-ion batteries, interpreting battery remains after thermal runaway for root cause analysis has become increasingly complex. To meet this challenge, Exponent is developing new methodologies and techniques to determine the cause and origin of catastrophic failures and the results of those efforts will be shared in this presentation.

4:00 pm

Failure and Material Analysis of Batteries with Si Anodes

Emily Klein, Materials Scientist, Energy Assurance

While Li-ion batteries are an amazing technological achievement to meet future energy requirements there is a need to develop higher energy batteries. For the past 20 years Si has been seen as a capable alternative to graphite due to it high specific capacity and in recent years there has been a rise in prototype production of Li-ion batteries containing a combination of Si and graphite or pure Si anodes. With the addition of Si, it is important to understand its role in cell failure and additional material analysis that will help tell the whole story. This presentation will aim to describe additional techniques that should be utilized in a cell teardown and a safety review to better understand how Si is impacting cell failure.

Close of Forensics & Post-Incident Diagnostics & Testing Conference4:30 pm